Common Mistakes in HSC Community & Family Studies

Sep 18, 2024

As a PDHPE and Community & Family Studies teacher with over 20 years of experience, I've seen students make the same mistakes time and time again in their HSC assessments. Let’s look at the five most common errors and provide strategies to help your learners avoid falling into these traps.

Qualitative vs. Quantitative Data

One fundamental concept students often misunderstand is the difference between qualitative and quantitative data. Qualitative data involves rich, descriptive information gathered through methods like observations, interviews and case studies. It focuses on in-depth details rather than numbers. 

Quantitative data, on the other hand, is numerical - things like statistics, trends and values represented in graphs or charts. It's less prone to bias since it deals with objective measurements rather than subjective opinions. 

When teaching this distinction, I find it helpful to use the mnemonic "QUAL is qualitative, QUAN is quantitative." Emphasise that qualitative looks at opinions and experiences through words, while quantitative examines amounts through figures. Give examples of each type from research studies to cement the definitions. Regularly assessing student understanding can catch and correct lingering confusion.

Reliability vs. Validity in Research

Another area causing issues is distinguishing reliability from validity in research methodology. Reliability refers to the consistency and repeatability of measurement tools and processes.
A reliable study would produce similar results under the same conditions. 

Validity concerns the accuracy of the data collected. A valid study measures what it sets out to using an appropriate sample and relevant questions. 

Validity demands the right sample and focused questions to answer the research question accurately. Practising examples together helps untangle these tricky terms.

Policies vs. Legislation

Students also commonly confuse policies and legislation. Legislation refers to laws passed by governments, which if broken incur penalties. Policies, on the other hand, are guidelines or plans of action - sometimes created in response to legislation or data.

When teaching this, provide clear examples of each. The Racial Discrimination Act is legislation, while the Close the Gap initiative is a policy. Emphasise policies can be implemented by various levels of government or organisations. Regularly testing comprehension with practice questions prevents policies and legislation being lumped together.

Government Agencies vs. Community Organisations 

Another mix-up arises between government agencies and community organisations. Government agencies are formal support services run directly by the state or federal administration, such as Centrelink or Medicare. 

Community organisations are non-government groups providing assistance, like Meals on Wheels or the Salvation Army. They may receive government funding but operate independently. 

Use examples to demonstrate the distinction. Provide opportunities to correctly classify new organisations. Checking responses builds confidence in telling apart these similar yet separate entity types.

Roles in Parenting and Caring 

Finally, students tend to gloss over demonstrating the interrelationship between roles in parenting and caring. The key roles involve promoting wellbeing, building relationships, and meeting needs - but examples are needed to link them together.

Brainstorm daily activities embodying each role, such as preparing healthy meals (meeting needs), family game nights (building relationships), or taking a child to the doctor (promoting wellbeing). Regularly practising integrating examples strengthens understanding of how the roles interconnect in real life.

By addressing these five common mistakes, Community & Family Studies learners can avoid typical pitfalls and perform to their best ability in their HSC assessments. The strategies aim to clarify muddy concepts and cement comprehension to help all students succeed.